PUBLIC SCORING CHARTER
Public Scoring Charter
This page sets out how we score and rank tools: the five dimensions and their weights, how ranking works, how seats are allocated, when tools enter or leave the list and the museum, and how we fix mistakes. Every rule here corresponds to a program actually running on the site.
Article 1
Five commitments
These are our five commitments for every score; anything we cannot actually do is not listed here.
Article 2
Five-Dimension Weights
The AMPM Score is a weighted average of five dimensions. What each one looks at: Utility = whether AMO and PIMI's hands-on review ends in a clear recommendation; Value = where the price sits within its category, plan flexibility, free allowance and lock-in terms; Accessibility = the free tier and how honest it is, Chinese-language and Taiwan payment friendliness, and whether there is a trial; Reliability = how many verification records have built up, how recently the tool was last checked, and how stable its prices are; Momentum = whether there has been recent news or price activity. The item-by-item calculation inside each dimension is kept for audit and is not published tool by tool.
Article 3
How scores are used for ranking
- Within a category: tools are ranked by AMPM Score, highest first, within each category.
- Ties: when scores tie, reader attention (search impressions and clicks) decides the order; clicks and traffic never count toward the score itself.
- Grades: 75 and above is Excellent, 65 and above Good, 55 and above Fair, and anything lower Needs work.
Article 4
Tool status and lifecycle
At any point in time, every listed tool is in one of the following states. Missing data does not mean a poor product, and a failure of AMPM's own verification process is never held against the tool.
| Status | What it means |
|---|---|
| Active main-list member | Holds an AMPM100 seat. Newly listed tools are protected for their first 14 days and cannot be replaced. |
| Under observation | During the first 7 days after being added, the system collects official pricing, plan and identity verification data. |
| Verified | Official sources and key data are confirmed; the tool is eligible for the ranking and seat allocation. |
| Pending verification (overdue) | Verification still incomplete on days 8-14: the reason is noted and re-checks stay scheduled; the product is not judged unqualified. |
| Ranking suspended | Required verification still incomplete after 14 days: formal ranking eligibility is suspended and records are kept pending new evidence; this is not a permanent ban. |
| Dropped from the current list | Ranked lower only because competitors scored higher; eligibility is intact and the tool can return to the top 100 by score at any time. |
| Probation period | When a listed tool shows abnormal official data or contradictory key figures, it gets 14 days to recover; its seat is kept and a warning is shown. |
| Museum archive | Once formally listed, then archived because the probation period ended without recovery or the service stopped: the best past rank, reason for leaving and score snapshot are kept permanently, and the tool may return to active status if it later qualifies. |
Article 5
Group seats and the challenger swap mechanism
AMPM100 keeps the twelve original tool categories. For ranking, every two categories are merged into one group — six groups in all, each ranked up to 100. While a group is not full, a tool is listed once it passes verification; once full, a challenger must beat the lowest-scoring member for 7 days in a row to take a seat.
When a group has open seats, a qualified tool that passes the eight-gate verification is listed directly; once a group is full at 100, a challenger must score <b>higher than the group's lowest-scoring non-protected member for 7 days in a row</b> to be promoted. New entries get a <b>14-day protection period</b> to keep the list stable and fair.
Article 6
Ranking museum (rule v3)
The museum is a continuously observed historical archive. Rule v3 applies from 2026-10-19: tools that were once formally listed and then did not recover after the probation period, or stopped operating, move to the museum. Archived tools keep their best historical rank, last valid score, date of leaving and the specific reason. Historical snapshots and data are kept permanently for verification; history is never erased.
Museum archiving is not a permanent ban. If an archived tool resumes normal operation, re-establishes official sources and passes full verification again, it may return to compete on the active list under the current scoring rules. /museum/
Article 7
Corrections and historical snapshots
If you think a score or a figure is wrong, tell us through the contact page; once verified, we fix the data itself and every place that uses it, and the correction record is published at /audit/. Every ranking period is kept as a non-overwritable historical snapshot, so anyone can trace past scores and ranking history.
