Scoring Methodology & Commercial Separation Policy | AMPM
⚖️ AMPM100 Scoring Methodology & Integrity Standards
Core commitments: No paid rankings | Evidence is public | Commercial separation
- Source priority and cross-checking: the vendor's official main pricing page is the first source, and every record notes its source URL and check date. If an FAQ/terms page or a third-party hands-on test says something different, we record both and flag the difference. Honest status: most records currently rest on a single official source; second and third sources are being added record by record.
- No fabrication: if we can't find it, we honestly mark it "not found". We never make up numbers to make the page look complete.
- Every entry is dated: every data point carries the timestamp of its last actual check.
- Usefulness (30%): what the tool can actually do, and whether it is useful to ordinary people.
- Value for money (25%): whether the free quota is enough, whether paid plans are worth it, and whether there are hidden billing traps.
- Ease of getting started (15%): whether you can start using it without reading a manual, Traditional Chinese support, and how convenient payment is from Taiwan.
- Reliability (20%): whether official data can be verified, whether the service is still operating, and whether data conflicts have been resolved.
- Growth (10%): whether there have been substantive recent updates (new features, price adjustments, model upgrades).
Correction 2026-09-12: this page previously stated "three main dimensions 40 / 35 / 25", which did not match the site's actual scoring program. It has been corrected to the program's weights.
How we check prices: the full process from “finding a number” to “daring to publish it”
The three iron rules above are the principles; this section is how we actually do it. Every rule corresponds to a program that is really running on the site — these are not slogans written for show.
1. Source tiers: official pricing page > official documentation > third party
For every price or quota, we first ask “who said this?”:
- Official pricing page (e.g. replit.com/pricing, console.groq.com/docs/rate-limits): highest tier. If the pricing page and any other place disagree on the same point, the pricing page wins.
- Official documentation, help centre, terms: second tier. Used to fill in details the pricing page omits (refund window, rate limits, credit expiry rules).
- Third party (review sites, blogs, price-comparison sites, communities): lowest tier. A third-party figure can never be published on its own. It may only be disclosed when the official page is blocked or silent, and the text must state “third-party source, not confirmed against the official site”.
Search-engine AI summaries do not count as a source. They are someone else’s digest, not the original text.
2. Two-pass: a change only counts once it has been “seen again the next day”
Price data on this site is not kept current by a person watching every day. A price-watching program on our server checks each vendor’s official pages on a regular schedule, and its method is deliberately simple:
- It does not parse prices; it only detects whether “this page has changed”. After each pricing page is fetched, only the text related to amounts and quotas is kept and a fingerprint is computed. If the fingerprint matches the previous one, the page is skipped.
- On most days it doesn’t even need to download the content. It uses conditional requests (ETag / If-Modified-Since); a 304 from the server means nothing changed, at zero cost.
- A changed fingerprint does not immediately change the data. The first sighting of a change is recorded only as “suspected”; the page is fetched again at least 20 hours later, and only if both fetches differ from the old one and the two new fingerprints agree is it promoted to “confirmed change”. That is the two-pass: a single observation never counts. It guards against A/B-test pages, regional pricing and temporary error pages being mistaken for a price increase.
- All records are append-only. Every fetch result, every confirmed change, and a raw snapshot of the page on the day of the change are written as append-only files, so you can go back later and check “what exactly was seen that day”.
After a change is confirmed, a person (or the system, by rule) still has to apply it to the site’s data. That step has three locks: the two-pass really did pass; the current value on the site equals the “old value” in the record (guarding against someone having edited it manually in between); and when applying, the price file, the evidence file and the history file must all three be written successfully — if any one fails, everything is rolled back. Changes to free quotas are applied automatically and logged as “approved by the system under two-pass” if the new value is single and unambiguous; price changes are always left for a human, because annual-billed monthly-equivalent prices and monthly list prices are far too easy to confuse, and a machine should not decide that for people.
3. Verification stamps: stamped only on a successful fetch; otherwise we say so
A tool page shows two dates with different meanings:
- “Price last confirmed”: the date a person manually checked each item, stored in the data file’s last_verified field. This stamp is only applied after a human check.
- “Latest automatic check”: the last time the price watcher successfully read that tool’s pricing page, pulled from the watcher’s own state file — not entered by a person. If a tool has never been fetched successfully, this field is blank and the page honestly shows “no record yet” instead of filling in a fake date.
If the manual check date is more than 14 days old, the page label automatically changes to “Last manual check”, reminding you that no one has looked at this figure for a while.
4. Handling blocks: 403 does not mean “does not exist”
Many official pages return 403 or 429 to automated connections, or are rendered entirely by JavaScript so that a static fetch only gets an empty shell. Our rules:
- 403 / 429 means “blocked”, not “not found”, and certainly not “does not exist”. Only a 404 may be used as one piece of evidence that a page does not exist.
- Sources that plain HTTP cannot fetch are handed to the second leg: a real browser (Playwright) opens the page, waits for JavaScript to finish rendering, then reads it — likewise zero AI, zero cost. The two legs keep separate state, because the “static text” and “rendered text” fingerprints of the same page are necessarily different, and mixing them would make them cancel each other out.
- A source that fails three times in a row backs off for 24 hours before retrying — no brute-force retries, no provoking an official block.
- If both legs fail, the tool page is marked “official page could not be read automatically”, and the article states “official page blocked; the following is from third-party sources”. We never pass off third-party figures as official just because a fetch failed.
5. How we fix mistakes: fix the root cause, keep a record, sync every reference
We do make mistakes, and there are real cases on the site. The rules for fixing them:
- First trace it to “which sentence, which field” was wrong, and fix the root cause rather than the symptom. For example, we once wrote an “annual-billed monthly equivalent” as a “monthly list price”; the fix was not to change that one number, but to re-scan every field of the same type.
- A fix must be synced to every place that references it: tool page, comparison page, guide articles, conclusion sentences. Changing the data without changing the references is the same as not changing it.
- Every change leaves a traceable record: price changes have a public price change log; every edit to a data file carries a time and a basis; evidence files are append-only.
- Corrections are marked directly in the article. Where an official site contradicts itself (e.g. two different numbers on the same page), we list both, with dates, rather than picking one on the vendor’s behalf.
6. How you can verify us
Every article ends with “Sources” and “Last verified”; tool pages show the verification date and source links; the Scoring Charter explains how scores are computed; the Disclosure page explains our relationships with vendors. If you see any figure that differs from the official site, please tell us via the contact page; we will handle it under the process in section 5 above and leave a record.
This section was added on 2026-09-04 and corresponds to the price watcher, change-application and pre-deployment check programs actually running on the site; if the program logic changes, this page is updated in step.
How AMPM100 seats are earned and swapped: the eight gates and the replacement rules
Seats are recomputed by a program on a regular schedule under the rules below. The one current exception is the scoring transition that began on 2026-09-30: by the site’s decision, the 7 tools that the old, distorted score had pushed out were returned to the list, and removing tools from an over-quota category by score is paused until the new scoring goes live.
The eight gates (all must pass before a tool can take a seat)
- Evidence coverage ≥ 80%: the proportion of the five dimensions backed by verifiable evidence; below 80% no seat is granted.
- Zero unresolved major data conflicts: if sources disagree on a figure and it has not been cleared up, the tool cannot be listed.
- At least four of five dimensions valid: tools with too little data are not scored.
- Primary category confirmed: whether it is a chatbot or an image generator must be settled first.
- Product identity and continuity confirmed: we confirm it is still alive, has not been renamed, and has not shut down.
- Pricing / free-plan evidence valid: for priced tools, the price and free quota must have an official source.
- Key facts double-verified: key figures such as price and quota must be found consistent in two independent checks.
- Seat status legitimate: not on probation and not in the museum.
Replacement, probation, museum
- Passes all eight gates and the category has an open seat → listed.
- When a category is full, a challenger must score higher than the lowest-scoring full member in that category for 7 consecutive days to take the seat.
- A full member that fails a gate or is replaced → 21 days of probation (data remains available and it can re-qualify) → not back on the list when it ends → moves into the museum (if the historical evidence is not enough, entry is deferred and it returns to the challenger list first).
- A formerly listed tool that shuts down → moves into the museum directly and is labelled as such.
- Newly listed tools get a 14-day protection period, so they are not replaced right after joining.
The museum (rule v2, from 2026-10-16)
- The museum is a continuously observed historical archive: it keeps tools that once held a seat, with their listing and removal records, the reason they were removed, the score at entry and the last verification.
- Entry depends only on public criteria: the tool held a seat, did not return when its probation ended, and has enough historical evidence (an official website, a check date and verification records). Having a partnership or not makes no difference, and the museum page carries no ad or recommendation cards.
- We keep checking museum tools’ prices and plans and tracking their news and service status; new data is only added and never overwrites the history.
- Museum tools do not automatically take part in the current ranking; the score at entry is a historical record, not the current score or an endorsement.
- Challengers that never held a seat do not enter the museum for now.
- When the rule took effect, formerly listed tools that had been sent back to the challenger list on 2026-10-09 and 10 under the old rule were added under the new rule, and their records note the date.
What a challenger is
Challenger = a tool that does not hold a seat yet: either it has not passed all eight gates, or it has passed them but its category is full and it is waiting for a seat. The challenger page shows how many gates remain and which ones are blocking; tools in a full category challenge under the replacement rule above.
Cross-category fill seats
When a category has no eligible tool, its open seat goes to the highest-scoring tool site-wide that has passed all eight gates; the fill seat is given back as soon as an eligible tool appears in that category.
Every rule in this section corresponds to a program actually running on the site; if a rule changes, this page changes with it. Last updated: 2026-10-16 (museum rule v2).
